A rider steps off BART at the 24th and Mission station. (Photo: Anthony Lazarus)

As the COVID-19 pandemic spreads, entire sectors of the global economy are coming to a screeching halt as consumers are forced to stay home and service workers are laid off. The Bay Area’s public transit systems are facing similar catastrophic losses — but transit cannot shut down. In fact, it must maintain close to normal capacity to promote social distancing among the few riders left.

As with almost every sector of society, the need for relief is urgent. Local transportation leaders and activists are sounding the alarm, petitioning for emergency funding to save transit agencies from total austerity.

“The only certainty we have now is that our budget situation is completely unpredictable,” said SF Municipal Transportation Agency director of transportation Jeffrey Tumlin during a budget meeting broadcast online Thursday. “We know that significant budget and service cuts are coming, and we need to prepare.”

But it’s unclear when relief is coming. Before adjourning to shelter in place themselves, California lawmakers authorized a $1 billion emergency package, with half to be spent immediately at Governor Gavin Newsom’s discretion. There’s no word yet if any of that cash will come to the rescue of transit.

Likewise with federal money. An $8.3 billion emergency package, the first in a wave, earmarked $950 million for state and local governments. But in open letters this week that appealed to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and California senators Dianne Feinstein and Kamala Harris for relief, Bay Area Rapid Transit board president Lateefah Simon said it was unclear if her agency could apply for the federal funding.

‘Particularly vulnerable’

With the uncertainty, transit officials and advocates have begun lobbying hard. A national transit trade group is asking Congress for a $16 billion package. In Congress, Reps. Chuy Garcia of Illinois and Gwen Moore of Wisconsin, both Democrats, issued a letter to Senate and House leaders also calling for $16 billion to fund transit. Locally, BART’s Simon asked for emergency funding immediately. BART announced Thursday it would reduce service hours, now starting at 8 am and ending at 9 pm. One of BART’s strengths — a farebox recovery ratio of 60%, one of the highest ratios in the country, according to Simon — is now a debilitating weakness. “We are particularly vulnerable to the loss of fare revenue during catastrophic events,” Simon wrote. BART has lost 88% of its ridership and faces losses up to $55 million a month from lower ridership and less sales tax revenue during a recession.

SFMTA, which runs the Muni subway, buses, and parking, faces weekly losses of $1 million, and will reduce service on some Muni lines to Sunday service.

The newly-formed Transbay Coalition, a collection of grassroots activist groups which formed to campaign for bus lanes on the Bay Bridge, circulated two petitions — one for state and regional leaders, and one for the federal government — calling for an emergency cash infusion. Bay Area representatives in the state legislature, including state Senator Scott Wiener of San Francisco and Assembly member Bill Quirk of Hayward, have echoed calls for emergency funding but haven’t made requests for specific dollar amounts.

“We have to step in with an emergency cash infusion to save our transit systems, because essential workers are still relying on them to get to work,” Wiener said on an Instagram Live Q&A on Friday morning, adding that both the state and Congress would need to provide funds.

In the East Bay, the AC Transit bus system reported a 40% drop in ridership last week and expects it to drop to 90%, with $1.1 million losses in weekly fare revenue. When asked about service cuts, AC Transit board vice president Elsa Ortiz told The Frisc: “We are looking at everything. We haven’t made any decisions yet.”

Pre-pandemic deficits

To make matters worse, local transit systems were already facing steep challenges. SFMTA’s Tumlin said Thursday that before the pandemic arrived his agency was already projecting a $66 million budget deficit for fiscal year 2021.

The fear of a so-called “death spiral” is real: a negative feedback loop in which reduced service begets lower ridership, which in turn triggers more service cuts. Tumlin posed the key issue: “Do we keep fares the same or cut service, given the reality of our budget?”

1*KY2hNPr-M6hhKaXs4fguSQ
Muni’s N-Judah train in less fraught times. (Photo: Jeremy LaCroix)

“In many ways, we’ve only just recovered from many of the cuts that came as a result of the 2008 financial crisis,” said Ian Griffiths, founder of Seamless Bay Area, a constituent group of the Transbay Coalition. He knows more cuts are coming, but warns that “if you don’t have reliable service, you can’t convince people to take transit. Even when coronavirus is gone, people may be reluctant to ride.”

‘At the end of this tunnel, we’ll still have a climate crisis and economic inequality, and we’ll need public transportation as part of the solution.’

— Friends of Caltrain cofounder Adina Levin

Tumlin also cautioned that service cuts would do more damage to ridership than would fare increases — a thorny subject even in normal times. Muni as recently as last month cited a driver shortage as a reason to contemplate fare increases, which rankled many people including newly elected District 5 Supervisor Dean Preston. Free Muni was a key plank of Preston’s campaign, and though it appears to be a nonstarter when the need for funding is so dire, policymakers may be forced to reconsider how much our systems can rely on paying riders in times of crisis.

Tumlin’s data on “demand elasticity” indicated that when service is cut, more affluent riders flee for car trips, and poorer transit riders stick to less convenient transit; when the agency raises fares, riders typically pony up.

Big ideas on hold

Major capital improvement wish lists — a second Transbay Tube, anyone? — have also been put on hold with the shelving of a proposed regional transit funding measure known as FASTER Bay Area.

But with lower ridership now an epidemiological necessity, our region’s transportation system faces the daunting challenge of weathering the storm without going bankrupt.

Ultimately, activists and leaders agree that stopping the bleeding is critical, but long-term reform that ties the region together is more important than ever.

As SFMTA’s Tumlin said Thursday evening: “It’s not necessarily that I’m a better person when I ride a bike or a bus [instead of a car], but I take up one-tenth of the space.”

San Jose State University student Monica Mallon, a South Bay public transit activist, said she wants to see dollars for highways reallocated around the region for transit. “There are so many [highway] projects on the books that don’t make sense,” Mallon noted. “If people are willing to come together, this is a time to really rethink our priorities and get things right.”

With drastic reductions in automobile trips, air quality in Los Angeles and the Bay Area has improved enormously. Once the pandemic has passed, however, cars will be back on the roads. How many is the question. Transportation officials and advocates, like Friends of Caltrain cofounder Adina Levin, want to ensure that transit alternatives are ready to pick up the slack when we all can move about again.

“At the end of this tunnel, however long and dark it is, we’ll still have a climate crisis and economic inequality,” said Levin, “and we’ll still need public transportation as part of the solution.”

Diego Aguilar-Canabal is a writer, political activist, and freelance journalist based in Berkeley, CA.

Leave a comment